Tales of Abundance

Thanksgiving Family Guilt: Who Gets a Seat at Your Table?

Tales of Abundance · Episode 100 Companion · Family

You can love someone, even forgive them, and still decide how much of your holiday they get. Anthony Marino's test for holiday family guilt is simple: show up where your effort lifts other people up. And it's okay to drop the traditions you only keep out of guilt or habit.

In Episode 100, "Ben Franklin Cut Off His Only Son. Who Gets a Seat at Your Table?", Randy Lorensen and Anthony Marino talk honestly about what showing up for the holidays costs, and when it's worth it.

TL;DR

  • Ben Franklin answered his Loyalist son's letter but never fully let him back in.
  • A lot of holiday stress starts before you arrive. Anthony calls it feeling "pre-hurt."
  • You have options: split the day, zoom in, let the kids skip the trip, or buy the lasagna.
  • Ask Randy's question about every tradition: are you doing it on purpose, or out of guilt and old habits?

What happened between Ben Franklin and his son?

Randy opens the episode in a thunderstorm in 1752. Ben Franklin is flying a kite with a key on the string, and the one person he brought along is his son, William.

William later became Royal Governor of New Jersey. In 1775 the father picked America and the son picked the king. William was arrested in 1776 and held in solitary confinement, and his famous father did nothing to help.

In 1784 William wrote to his father. Ben wrote back that nothing had ever hurt him so much as being deserted in his old age by his only son, and that they would try to forget what happened, "as well as we can." (You can read the full 1784 letter at Founders Online.) They met once more in 1785. Franklin died five years later and left William almost nothing in his will.

Randy's read on it: "He opened the door enough to write, he never opened it all the way."

Then he turned it on Anthony. Thanksgiving is coming. Can you love someone? "Even forgive them? Still not decide to give them a seat at your table?"

Why do the holidays feel so heavy for some families?

Anthony brought the topic, and he was open about why. For years the holidays meant arguments with his wife, Jan, about where to go, when, where to stay and who they'd see.

Worse was knowing who'd be there. You're "pre-hurt," he said, "because you're gonna have to sit across the table from a particular person or persons."

For him that was his father, who "was the head of the table, whatever he said goes." Add the cousins and uncles and old grudges and drinking. One feud got so serious that the families "had to have a good old fashioned Italian sit-down to try to build the bridge between the two."

Where does holiday guilt come from?

Randy asked why Anthony kept going back to Boston as a grown adult. His answer: "Even though we didn't want to, we felt guilty if we didn't go."

Around 1983, he and Jan were young, living in Atlanta, with entry-level jobs and a good excuse to skip Easter. Easter was his mother's biggest holiday. They scraped together money for two plane tickets and surprised her.

Her joy stuck with them. They learned "we were bringing a lot of joy to people by us showing up at the table, that became just part of our DNA." Anthony said he'd never connected those dots until he prepped for this episode.

Is showing up for the holidays worth it?

Randy can see both sides. There's stress and travel and guilt. But "part of good relationships is sometimes we do things we don't necessarily want to do for the other person."

His own college Thanksgivings were easy to look forward to. His grandma knew how much he loved her stuffing. She'd make a big pan for 30 people, then a second pan just for him to take back to school. He'd bring the empty pan home at Christmas and she'd fill it again. As he put it, "there wasn't all the stress. There was more merriment." (Randy wrote a whole essay on what his grandma taught him about abundance.)

Anthony agreed that his story is his story. If your family gatherings work for you, he said, "then by all means you should run" toward them.

How do you handle holiday stress with an abundance mindset?

Randy walked through the usual stress points one at a time and asked Anthony how he'd handle each from a place of abundance.

What if two families want you on the same day?

For Anthony it was his side and Jan's side. "I wanted to make her happy and she wanted to make me happy." So they found a way to be in both places and accepted the sacrifice that came with it. Randy, whose parents divorced when he was young, grew up in the middle of two schedules. His hope is that both sides are reasonable and work it out.

What if the trip itself is the problem?

Anthony's new idea: "maybe I would zoom in instead of flying in." Put the video on the big screen all day, eat with whoever lives close and watch the games together.

He's already let one kid off the hook. His daughter and her husband are both in education, and they used to fly in Wednesday night and leave Sunday. A few years ago Anthony and Jan told them, "we don't want to put you guys through this hell." She'd never once said she didn't want to come. When they released her, "it was like, breath of fresh air."

What about the cooking and cleaning?

Randy is hosting this year and has been told the windows need cleaning. Anthony's answer was catering. He once spent three brutal days making lasagna for a family party and calls it "the stress of pleasing people." Most of it isn't needed. "They would be just as happy to go to the local supermarket and pick up a tray of lasagna."

Why didn't politics split the table back then?

Randy doesn't remember politics breaking up family dinners when he was a kid. Anthony remembers Vietnam arguments in the early '70s with uncles who were veterans, but nobody stopped talking over it the way some families do now.

Anthony's theory is the echo chamber. People are "in their personal echo chamber hearing the same thing over and over," until their minds close. He changed his own opinions five or six times in the '70s and early '80s, depending on who he was around. "You don't have to be this way for the rest of your life."

If a hard conversation is coming, our earlier episode on how to handle conflict with a friend is a good companion listen.

So who gets a seat at your table?

Randy and his wife, Julie, used to host an orphans' Thanksgiving on the Wednesday night before the holiday, for friends with no family nearby. It grew every year until the house was overflowing and Julie was buried in prep. He loved bringing all those people together, and he still called it off: "it's not worth the stress." They haven't hosted it in years.

His takeaway is one question for every tradition. Are we doing it with intention, "or are we doing it out of guilt and stress and old habits?"

Anthony's last word was about who's on the other end of the trip. Look down the road and ask, "is there someone there or some group of people there that really is going to enjoy your company." If so, go, and "do it with an intent to create abundance." Not in a way that drags your life down, he said, "but it lifts others up, including those in your immediate family." If that person isn't there, step back and decide what's in your best interest.

Before you book the flight

  • ☐ Name the person at that table who'll be glad you came.
  • ☐ Would you pick this tradition again today?
  • ☐ Try a video call or a shorter visit if the trip is the hard part.
  • ☐ Ask your grown kids if they're only coming because they think you expect it.
  • ☐ Buy the lasagna.

What else is in Episode 100?

It's our 100th episode. Thank you for listening. The second half is The Abundance Briefing, our weekly good-news segment. This week: a one-shot CRISPR therapy that cut LDL cholesterol 52.5%, AI agents running a biology lab, a 101-year-old running the 50 meters, Greece's comeback and SpaceX catching Starship with the tower.

FAQ: holiday family guilt

How do I deal with guilt about not going home for Thanksgiving?

Start with Randy's question: are you going on purpose, or out of guilt and old habits? If there's someone there who'll be glad you came, the trip may be worth it. If not, it's okay to stay home or find another way to connect.

Can you forgive a family member and still keep your distance?

Yes. That's the Ben Franklin story the episode opens with. Franklin wrote back to his son and agreed to try to forget the past, but he never opened the door all the way. Forgiving someone and deciding how much access they get are two separate choices.

What are alternatives to traveling for the holidays?

Anthony suggests zooming in instead of flying in: keep a video call running all day and eat with whoever is close. You can also tell grown kids they don't have to make a hard trip. His daughter felt real relief when he did.

How do I make hosting Thanksgiving less stressful?

Do less. Anthony hires out the cleaning and says most guests would be just as happy with a store-bought tray of lasagna. Randy and his wife ended a big yearly gathering when the stress outgrew the fun.

Who hosts Episode 100 of Tales of Abundance?

Randy Lorensen and Anthony Marino. The episode was released November 18, 2026, and runs 53:46.

Hear the whole conversation. Listen to Episode 100, then subscribe to Tales of Abundance on Apple Podcasts or Spotify so you never miss an episode.